Tuscarawas County, OH – Authorities say an Ohio mother allegedly commanded her husband and young son to enter a lake as part of a disturbing “spiritual delusion,” resulting in both deaths. Police allege the woman — a member of an Amish church — believed God was speaking to her and demanded the pair “prove their worthiness,” leading to the tragic drownings.
Disturbing Allegations of Faith-Based Tests
Tuscarawas County Sheriff Orvis Campbell described the events during a Monday press conference streamed. According to Campbell, the mother instructed Marcus Miller, 45, and his 4-year-old son, Vincen, to jump into Atwood Lake. She allegedly told investigators that these acts were “tests from God,” with Marcus initially believing he failed because of insufficient faith.
Witnesses reported Marcus was last seen at the dock around 6:30 a.m., while the woman was later seen driving dangerously near the lake with Vincen in her vehicle at 8 a.m. Campbell said she eventually threw Vincen into the water as an “offering to God”.
Other Children Forced Into Religious Tasks
The woman is also accused of coercing her remaining children — a 15-year-old daughter and 18-year-old twin sons — to perform similar lake-based “faith exercises.” Campbell said the children were made to lie on the dock, pray, and participate in bizarre tasks, such as putting their hands in the water to honor their deceased father and brother. Shortly afterward, she allegedly crashed a golf cart with the children inside, ignoring offers of assistance and insisting they continue praying.
Reports of “Bizarre” Faith Exercises
Authorities detailed some of the unusual exercises Marcus Miller was subjected to, including swimming tasks and other commands the mother said were directed by God. At one point, she reportedly claimed God instructed her to be “swallowed by a fish.” Campbell said the family initially returned to their RV after a failed test before going back to the lake at 5:30 a.m. to continue the rituals.
Amish Church Background and Weekend Trip
The Millers were identified as members of the Old Order Amish Church, living in Holmes County. Campbell noted that the family’s visit to Atwood Lake was intended as a weekend trip and “was not a premeditated plan.
Investigation and Public Safety
The female suspect has allegedly confessed to investigators. Police are awaiting formal charges and have not released her name publicly. Authorities are continuing their investigation into the events at Atwood Lake, which have left a community reeling and a family devastated.
What are your thoughts on how faith can sometimes lead to dangerous decisions? Share your perspectives in the comments below.
