West Valley City, UT – A Utah father and his girlfriend have been arrested and charged with child torture after investigators say they starved a 5-year-old girl so severely that she resorted to eating Play-Doh, wax, and even her own feces in an attempt to stay alive. Prosecutors described the case as one of the most disturbing acts of child abuse they have seen in years.
The Incident: Child Found Severely Malnourished After Hospital Visit
According to a probable cause affidavit, the investigation began on August 30, when David Fivas, 32, brought his 5-year-old daughter to a hospital, claiming she was not gaining weight and was eating feces. Doctors immediately noticed signs of extreme starvation, reporting that the girl weighed roughly the same as a typical 16-month-old child.
Medical staff said that after just over two weeks of consistent meals, the child gained nearly 9 pounds, a sign that malnutrition—not medical illness—was the cause of her alarming condition.
Investigators said Fivas admitted he “resented” the girl and believed she was “stealing food,” which led him and his girlfriend, Jessica Harmes, 44, to place child-proof locks on the refrigerator, cabinets, and pantry to restrict her access to food.
Investigation and Evidence of Starvation
Detectives with the West Valley City Police Department determined the abuse was intentional and long-term.
“The victim has been plummeting in health and growth for at least two years,” investigators wrote.
Authorities believe the girl began eating non-food items because she was being deprived of nutrition.
“A late-stage manifestation of starvation is overcoming revulsion to eat non-food items… eating feces is likely due to starvation,” the affidavit stated.
Fivas allegedly tried to mislead detectives by claiming the girl “overeats until she vomits,” but evidence suggested she was simply trying to survive. Meanwhile, another child living in the home showed no signs of starvation, further supporting claims of targeted abuse.
Additional findings revealed the girl was forced to sleep on the floor with only a blanket, was not enrolled in school, and appeared to be isolated intentionally.
Court Proceedings and Charges Filed
Fivas and Harmes have been charged with child torture—a felony offense under Utah law. During a bond hearing, prosecutors stressed the severity of the case:
“This goes beyond neglect. This is intentionally harming this child,” a prosecutor said.
Judge Richard W. Daynes denied Fivas’ release, stating:
“This individual is a danger to the community… The depravity of the allegations suggests far more than simple neglect.”
Authorities said Fivas attempted to surrender the girl to Child and Family Services after Harmes became pregnant, but the agency declined to take custody without legal grounds.
Harmes is also being held without bond, and both suspects remain in Salt Lake County Jail. Their next court dates are scheduled for late November.
Statements and Reactions
Neighbors and community members expressed horror at the allegations. Investigators noted that a second child in the home confirmed many details of the abuse.
“He didn’t want her and didn’t want to take care of her,” Harmes allegedly told investigators about Fivas’ feelings toward the child.
Child welfare authorities have since taken both children into state custody, where they are receiving care.
Background Context: Severe Child Starvation Cases
Local officials noted that cases involving intentional starvation often have long-lasting physical and psychological impacts on victims. Medical experts emphasize that signs of extreme malnutrition—such as eating non-food items—reflect serious, life-threatening deprivation.
This case adds to national concerns about child abuse hidden behind closed doors and has renewed calls for stronger oversight, mental health interventions, and mandatory welfare check improvements.
Ongoing Developments and What Comes Next
Fivas’ next court hearing is scheduled for November 24, while Harmes awaits her next court appearance. Prosecutors say additional charges could be considered as the investigation continues.
Officials have not yet disclosed the long-term plans for the children but confirmed both are now safe and receiving necessary medical and social support.
Conclusion
The accusations against David Fivas and Jessica Harmes reveal an alarming pattern of abuse that investigators say nearly cost a young girl her life. As the legal process moves forward, Utah officials stress the importance of protecting vulnerable children and ensuring accountability for those who inflict such harm.
What are your thoughts on this case? Share your opinions in the comments below.
