Erie, PA – A 37-year-old woman has been sentenced to 40 to 80 years in prison for the 2023 murder of 66-year-old Michael Maisner, where she shot him, dismembered his body with a chainsaw, and burned his remains in a backyard firepit.
Marisa Jean Rodriguez, of Erie, Pennsylvania, has been sentenced to up to 80 years in prison after pleading guilty but mentally ill to charges related to the brutal killing of Michael Maisner. Rodriguez admitted to shooting Maisner, dismembering him with a chainsaw, and burning his body in a firepit using his own money. The case has shocked the local community and prompted severe emotional responses from all involved.
The Crime: A Gruesome Murder Unfolds
The horrific crime came to light in April 2023, when Maisner’s family, unable to contact him for several days, visited his home. Upon arrival, they found no sign of Maisner but discovered Rodriguez hiding in the attic, where she had reportedly been living for months. Authorities later uncovered chilling evidence at the home, including human tissue, bloodstains, and disturbing writings on the walls.
Investigators soon discovered charred human remains and bone fragments in a firepit behind the house, which were later confirmed through DNA to be Maisner’s. In addition, Rodriguez was linked to the crime through disturbing online searches, including phrases like “how to shoot someone,” “how to burn a dead body,” and “cutting a dead body with a chainsaw.”
A Motive and Method: Dissecting Rodriguez’s Actions
Rodriguez’s motive appeared to stem from her tumultuous relationship with Maisner, who had allowed her to stay in his home to help with household tasks. However, the shocking turn of events saw Rodriguez not only kill Maisner but also use his financial resources to purchase the chainsaw and other items needed to dispose of his body. Surveillance footage showed her purchasing a chainsaw with Maisner’s debit card, spending nearly $600 at a Walmart on April 3, 2023.
Rodriguez then drove Maisner’s car to New York, where she was arrested the following day on car theft charges. Upon interrogation, she admitted to living in Maisner’s attic but claimed she didn’t know how he died, despite her earlier actions.
Rodriguez’s Legal Proceedings: A Case of Mental Illness
Rodriguez’s trial was fraught with complications, including her initial diagnosis of schizophrenia, which led to her being deemed incompetent to stand trial in January 2023. However, she was later declared fit for trial and reached a plea deal with prosecutors. In August, she pleaded guilty but mentally ill to multiple felonies, including third-degree murder and abuse of a corpse.
Judge Daniel J. Brabender Jr., who presided over the case, called the circumstances “probably the worst series of facts I’ve probably ever heard in a courtroom” before sentencing Rodriguez to the maximum allowed under Pennsylvania law — 40 to 80 years in prison.
The Victim: Michael Maisner’s Final Days
Maisner, described by his family as a laid-back man who enjoyed life and had plans to resume golfing and motorcycling after recovering from hip surgery, was brutally taken from the world. His nephew, Adam Maisner, told local news that his uncle was simply trying to live a peaceful life when Rodriguez entered it, ultimately leading to his tragic end.
Maisner had reportedly allowed Rodriguez to stay in his home, but little did he know that his kindness would ultimately be repaid with violence. His family is now left to mourn the loss of a loved one in an unimaginably brutal manner.
Legal Implications: How the Case Unfolded in Court
The legal proceedings in this case have been as shocking as the crime itself. Rodriguez faced several charges, including criminal mischief, possession of an instrument of crime, and tampering with evidence. The prosecution ultimately downgraded the charge from first-degree murder to third-degree murder as part of the plea deal.
As the case unfolded, disturbing video evidence was presented in court, showing Rodriguez engaging in behavior that further pointed to her premeditated actions. Her admission in court, saying “I cut him up,” sealed her fate, ensuring she would be held accountable for the heinous crime she committed.
Conclusion: A Life Behind Bars
Rodriguez’s sentence serves as a grim reminder of the horrific violence that can stem from mental health struggles and volatile personal relationships. Her actions — cutting up and burning the body of a man who had been nothing but kind to her — shocked the community and the nation alike.
In a final statement, Judge Brabender called the crime one of the most disturbing he had ever encountered, and with Rodriguez’s sentencing, the case has come to a close. However, the lasting impact of this brutal murder will continue to haunt the family and community for years to come.
What are your thoughts on this tragic case? Share your comments below and engage in the conversation.
