Memphis, TN – A dispute over religion outside a local bar in Memphis turned deadly when pastor Ricky Floyd, 58, was fatally shot by a Tennessee woman, Samantha Marion, 42. Authorities say the incident occurred on March 12, and the case has since sparked heated debate over self-defense claims and the use of firearms during public altercations.
Charges Against Samantha Marion
Marion was initially charged with voluntary manslaughter, but a grand jury elevated the charges on August 26. She now faces:
- Second-degree murder
- Employing a firearm with intent to commit a felony
- Reckless endangerment with a deadly weapon
Marion’s trial date has not yet been set, though she remains free after posting $100,000 bond.
The Confrontation Outside Momma’s Bar
According to Marion’s defense attorney, Marion and Floyd engaged in an argument about religion outside Momma’s Bar. The disagreement reportedly escalated, with Floyd initially leaving in his vehicle before returning and approaching Marion.
Cellphone footage taken by Marion shows Floyd walking aggressively toward her while she repeatedly warns him to stop. The video, shared with local media by Marion’s attorney, is a central piece of evidence in her self-defense claim.
Police and Prosecution Perspective
During a preliminary hearing in June, Patrolman Cordell Boyd, the first officer on the scene, testified for the prosecution. Boyd questioned Marion’s claim of self-defense, suggesting that she had the option to leave the scene instead of retrieving her firearm from her vehicle.
Prosecutors also cited surveillance video, which allegedly shows:
- Floyd backing away at the moment Marion allegedly fired
- Floyd throwing beer cans and Marion’s phone leading up to the confrontation
Authorities maintain that these details challenge the narrative that Marion acted purely in self-defense.
Defense Statement
Marion’s attorney, John Keith Perry, defended his client’s actions, emphasizing that Floyd continued to approach her despite multiple warnings.
“She defended herself when she was facing grave, grave danger, and because of that, she is hurled into the criminal justice system, hopefully for a short period of time,” Perry said.
Perry noted that additional context from the confrontation was omitted from the arrest affidavit, suggesting there may be factors not fully captured in the official reports.
Current Status of the Case
Marion remains free pending trial after posting bond. Law enforcement and prosecutors continue to review evidence, including cellphone and surveillance videos, to determine the full scope of the events that led to Floyd’s death.
Attempts to reach the Shelby County District Attorney’s Office for comment were unsuccessful at the time of reporting.
Community Reactions and Safety Concerns
The shooting has raised concerns among local residents and faith communities. Questions surrounding religious disputes, public safety, and self-defense laws have prompted community dialogue on how to prevent similar tragedies.
Officials remind the public that:
- Escalating arguments in public spaces can become dangerous quickly
- Firearms should be used only as a last resort in life-threatening situations
- Law enforcement should be contacted when disputes show signs of turning violent
Conclusion
The tragic death of pastor Ricky Floyd highlights the complex intersection of self-defense claims, firearm use, and public confrontations. Samantha Marion’s upcoming trial will determine the legal consequences of the March 12 incident, while the community continues to grapple with the safety and legal implications of such disputes.
What are your thoughts on this tragic incident? Share your perspective in the comments below.
